NEW CARLISLE

INDIANA

112 Arch St.

New Carlisle, IN

The place to find Delicious Pizza, Hometown Hospitality, Bowling & More!
The Black Cat Bar & Grill Est. 1957
 The year Great Uncle Charlie became an apprentice Chicago Pizza Maker was a troubled and eventful year for America. The masterwork of a Pizza Maker could hardly warrant a place in history. Yet the culinary creativeness of young Charlie Oddo most certainly made its mark. In 1944 the people of Chicago were no strangers to great tasting pizza; nevertheless Mr. Oddo took it upon himself to start developing the pizza recipe that would later become a Windy City legend. After years of success, Uncle Charlie’s recipes passed to Great Nephew Vince Rizzo and for more than the last 35 years the legendary Rizzo Pizza has lived on at The Black Cat. The secret Rizzo Pizza Sauce and Dough are prepared fresh daily, even the Rizzo sausage is custom ground using the original secret recipe from the DiGirolamo Family. Our Story..
OUR MENU
HANDCRAFTED BURGERS HANDHELD SANDWICHES HOMEMADE RIZZO PIZZA

Served with Chips and Pickle

Upgrade: Fries +1.50, Tater Tots +2.00,

or Onion Rings +3.00

 

Choose your Cheese:

American, Swiss or Mozzarella

 

Bacon +1.50

Lettuce or Tomato +.50 each

Grilled Mushrooms or Onions +1.25 each

* Cat Burger *     1/4 pound

Single 7.00

Double 9.50

 

* Fat Cat Burger *     1/2 pound

Single 9.50

Double 16.00

 

Hi Roller Cat  8.00

Grilled onion, mushrooms, mayo, American cheese

 

Bacon Mushroom Swiss Fat Cat  12.50

 

Farmhouse Fat Cat  13.50

Fried egg, American cheese, bacon

 

Fat Cat Bacon Mac & Cheese  13.00

 

Pretzel Cat  9.50

Grilled onion, Belgian mustard, ham, Swiss

 

Bacon Double Cheese Cat  11.00

 

Texas Fat Cat  12.50

American cheese, bacon, onion ring, jalapeños, BBQ

 

Swiss & Baby Bella Fat Cat  12.50

Lightly breaded baby portabella, Swiss, garlic aioli

 

SHAREABLES & SIDES

Pepperoni Pinwheels  8.50

Pepperoni and mozzarella rolled in our dough baked golden brown

 

Cheese Curd Trio  9.00

Hand-breaded white, garlic & jalapeño

 

Crispy Onion Rings  5.00

 

Loaded Tots  8.00

Monterey jack & bacon with sour cream

 

Cheesy Garlic Bread  6.50

 

Mozzarella Cheese Sticks  6.00

 

Nachos 5.00

Fresh corn chips with jalapeño cheese sauce

 

Nacho Tot Bowl 5.00

Crispy tots smothered in jalapeño cheese sauce

topped with sour cream

 

Fries 3.00

Crinkle or straight

 

Tator Tots 4.00

 

Homemade Bread sticks  6.00

Oven fresh with pizza sauce or cheese sauce

 

Baby Bella Shrooms  8.50

Lightly breaded with pizza sauce

 

Mac & Cheese  4.50

 

Pretzel Bites  8.50

With beer cheese

 

Hand-breaded Chicken Strips  6.50

Crispy and hand-breaded with choice of ranch, BBQ or honey mustard

Served with Chips and Pickle

Upgrade: Fries +1.50, Tater Tots +2.00,

or Onion Rings +3.00

Philly Beef  11.00

Italian beef, onion, green pepper, mushroom, mozzarella

 

Rizzo Beef & Cheese  10.00

Italian beef, pizza sauce, mozzarella

 

Texas Chicken  12.50

Cheese, bacon, onion ring, jalapeños, BBQ

 

Breaded Cod  6.50

 

Ham and Swiss Stacker  9.00

Grilled on a pretzel bun

 

Rizzo Ham & Cheese  9.50

Ham, mozzarella, mayo

 

Grinder  9.50

Pepperoni, sausage, pizza sauce, mozzarella

 

Chicken Breast  8.50

Grilled or crispy

 

Pork Tenderloin  9.50

 

Swiss & Baby Bella Chicken  12.50

Lightly breaded baby bella mushroom, Swiss,

garlic aioli

 

French Dip  10.00

Italian beef, Au Jus

Add cheese +1.50

SOUP & SALADS

Choice of Dressing:

Ranch, Blue Cheese, Fat-free Italian,

Honey Mustard, or French

Dinner Salad  4.50

Crisp iceburg lettuce, tomato, mushroom, and  Monterey jack cheese

 

Antipasto Salad  10.50

Pepperoni, ham, mozzarella, tomato, pepperoncinis, black and green olives

 

Chef Salad  10.50

Grilled chicken, crispy chicken or ham,

lettuce, tomato, onion, green pepper, egg, mushroom, egg, Monterey jack cheese

 

Loaded Chili  4.50

Shredded cheese, onion, sour cream

 

Soup of the Day  4.50

"Original Recipe - Chicago Style Italian Pizza"

 

Sausage Crumbles, Pepperoni, Bacon, Ground Beef, Sausage, Ham, Mushroom, Onion, Green Pepper, Tomato, Green Olive, Black Olive, Jalapeños, Sauerkraut, Banana Pepper, Pineapple,

Traditional Thin Crust

                       Snack 7"        Small 10"        Large 14"

Cheese              6.00                8.00               14.00

Each Add On       .75                1.75                2.25

 

Chicago Style Deep Dish

allow at least 35 min

                        Small 10"        Large 14"

Cheese              10.00              16.00

Each Option       1.75                2.25

 

Specialty Pizza

                          Snack 7"        Small 10"        Large 14"

House Special     8.25               13.25               20.75

Sausage, jalapeños, sauerkraut

 

Five Meat             9.75               16.75               25.25

Sausage, pepperoni, ham, bacon, ground beef

 

Veggie                  8.25               13.25               20.75

Mushroom, green pepper, onion, tomato

 

The EBA               10.50               18.50               27.50

Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, ham, onion,

green pepper, green olives, black olives

No Substitutions or Additions

 

 

The ULTIMATE Feast 68.00

3 - Large Thin Crust Pizzas with ANY 3 Options

2 - Bread sticks with pizza sauce

 

The FAMILY Feast 26.00

One Large Thin Crust Pizza with ANY 3 Options

Bread sticks with pizza sauce

Cat tails with dipping sauce

 

Extreme Stuffed Deep Dish 36.00

allow at least 50 min

Mozzarella stuffed crust with your choice of

up to 3 toppings

 

Calzone

Cheese 8.00     Additional toppings +1.75 each

 

Sausage Crumbles, Pepperoni, Bacon, Ground Beef, Ham, Mushroom, Onion, Green Pepper, Tomato, Green Olive, Black Olive, Jalapeños, Sauerkraut, Banana Pepper, Pineapple

Cat Tails 4.50

Cinnamon sugar coated fried dough

w/ vanilla glaze or chocolate syrup

extra dip +1.25

Draft Beer

Miller Lite

Coors Light

Yuengling

Shiner Bock

Sun King WeeMac

Three Floyds Gumballhead

Founders All Day IPA

Greenbush StarChicken Shotgun

BEERS

Domestic

Miller Lite

Coors Light

Budweiser

Bud Light

Michelob Ultra

 

Craft

Ask for current selection

Import Bottles

Ask for current selection

 

Other

Cider Boys (Assorted)

High Noon (Assorted)

Bud Light Seltzer (Assorted)

Dine-In or Carry Out
BOWLING & MORE

$20 an hour/ per lane

Up to 6 people per lane

 

$1.50 shoe rental

 

Bowling Parties Available

Contact for Pricing

 

Plus Full Arcade On Site

MEYER'S ICE CREAM
ICE CREAM CONES SUNDAES NOVELTY TREATS

Vanilla

Kiddie 1.29      Small 1.59      Large 2.59

Waffle Cone 3.09

 

Premium Ice Cream Flavors

Kiddie 1.49      Small 1.85      Large 2.99

Waffle Cone 3.59

 

Crunch Coat +0.79 each

 

Hand-Dipped Cones

Single Dip Sugar/Cake Cone 2.79

Waffle Cone 3.79

 

Additional dips +1.49 each

 

Soft Serve

Vanilla, Strawberry, Pumpkin Pie, Cotton Candy,

Peach, Blue Moon, Peanut Butter, Coconut

 

Hand Dipped

Vanilla, Strawberry, Michigan Pot Hole, Cookie Dough, Chocolate Chip, Eskimo Kiss, Rainbow Sherbet,

Cool Mint Cookie, Birthday Cake, Milky Way,

Praline Pecan,  Cotton Candy, Peppermint,

Mac Island Fudge, Blueberry Muffin Top

SHAKES & MALTS

Chocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry,

Banana, Butterscotch, Cherry,

Crushed Pineapple, Red Raspberry

 

Kids Shake 2.99      Large 3.99

Extra thick +0.79

Premium Flavors +0.50 each

Whipped Topping, Nuts and a Cherry,

Hot Fudge, Chocolate, Butterscotch,

Caramel, Strawberry, Turtle,

Crushed Pineapple, Red Raspberry

 

Small 2.99      Large 3.79

Extra topping candy topping +0.79 each

Premium Flavors +0.50 each

HAND DIPPED SUNDAES

Whipped Topping, Nuts and a Cherry,

Hot Fudge, Chocolate, Butterscotch,

Caramel, Strawberry, Turtle,

Crushed Pineapple, Red Raspberry

 

Small 3.99      Large 5.59

Extra topping candy topping +0.79 each

Chocolate Frozen Banana 1.59

Mr. Peanut Bar 2.59

Popsicle 1.00

Ice Cream Sandwich 1.59

Homemade Chips-A-Lot Ice Cream Sandwich 2.79

SPLITS, SLUSH & FLOATS

ULTIMATE Banana Split 6.59

Any three premium flavors of soft serve ice cream, whipped topping, nuts and a cherry

 

HUGE Banana Split 5.59

Three mounds of Vanilla soft serve ice cream,

whipped topping, nuts and a cherry

 

Junior Banana Split 4.59

Two mounds of Vanilla soft serve ice cream,

whipped topping, nuts and a cherry

 

Barq's Root Beer Float 2.99

 

Slush

Blue Raspberry, Cherry, Lemon Lime, Grape, Orange

Small 1.29      Large 1.99

 

Slush Float

Small 2.29      Large 3.29

 

Joly Rancher Slush Float

Small 2.29      Large 3.29

 

Cattuccino 3.99

Hot fudge, Caramel, Butterscotch

HAND DIPPED SHAKES & MALTS

Made with Vanilla ice cream 4.99

 

Chocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry,

Chocolate Chip, Banana, Butterscotch, Cherry, Crushed Pineapple, Red Raspberry

COUGAR SUPREME

Oreo, Butterfinger, Cookie Dough,

M&M, Reese's Peanut Butter Cup,

Chewy Fudge Brownie

 

Small 3.59      Large 4.59

Extra stuff +0.50 each

Premium Flavors +0.50 each

COME VISIT US

HOURS

Mon-Thurs   10AM - 10PM

Friday           10AM - 11PM

Saturday       12PM - 11PM

Sunday         12PM - 10PM

EASTERN TIME

CALL US

574-654-3411

574-654-3111

LOCATION

112 South Arch Street

New Carlisle, IN  46552

The Black Cat © 2022 All Rights Reserved. Tara Ashlee Photo & Design